Menu Close

How To Tell If Your Circuit Breaker is a Bad Breaker?

Circuit breakers are like a safety net for our electronic devices. They glance over most of the everyday hazards and guard us against the bigger catastrophes. They enable us to understand how much of a strain our equipment can take before it reaches its breaking point, so we can act preemptively to prevent any huge disasters.

When you have a faulty circuit breaker, however, you risk electrical hazards that can cause a lot of damage and even injury. This makes it essential to know how to tell if your circuit breaker is a bad one.

How to Tell if a Circuit Breaker is Bad?

Being in the dark about what is going on with your circuit breaker can be frustrating and dangerous. Fortunately, there are a few key signs that will help you determine if your current breaker is functioning or not.

1. Buzzing or Humming Noises Coming from Wall Outlets

One of the tell-tale signs that a circuit breaker is bad is buzzing or humming noises coming from wall outlets. This sound indicates that the circuit breaker has been overloaded and is no longer able to perform its job properly. It usually occurs when too many high-voltage appliances are being used on the same circuit, resulting in an overload of current.

2. The Breaker Has Tripped Multiple Times

Have you noticed that the circuit breaker trips multiple times, even when only one or two appliances are connected to it? If so, then it means your circuit breaker is not up to the task of handling the load. How will you know if your breaker is tripping? A bad circuit breaker will often trip without any explanation.

3. Burning Smells or Sparks Coming from an Outlet

If you smell burning or notice sparks coming out of an outlet, then this is an indication that your circuit breaker is bad and needs to be replaced. This issue occurs when too much current passes through a circuit, resulting in the breaker failing to trip and allowing the electricity to flow uninterruptedly and causing sparks or a burning smell.

4. Old Age

In some cases, the circuit breaker can begin to malfunction simply because it is old. Over time, a circuit breaker can become worn down and start to lose its effectiveness. This means that it won’t be able to handle the same amount of current as when it was new. If your circuit breaker has been in use for over 10 years, then it might be time to start thinking about replacing it. This is a common problem in older homes.

What are the Signs that Lead to a Bad Breaker?

Recognizing the signs of a bad breaker can be tricky – but doing the due diligence is worth it! Here are some signs and things to do when you think your breaker is bad:

1. Look for Visible Signs of Damage

Check the breaker box or panel to see if there are any signs of warping, corrosion, scorching, or other forms of physical damage. This could be a sign that the circuit breaker has tripped multiple times and is not functioning properly.

On a general note, even if you have an old breaker, it shouldn’t look visibly damaged or corroded.

2. Frequent Circuit Breakers Tripping

If the circuit breaker trips more than a few times in an hour, then it could be a sign that something is wrong with it. It could also indicate that you have an overloaded circuit, so try to identify which appliance is causing the circuit overload and switch off the power supply to it.

3. Listen for Strange Noises Coming from Your Breaker

You should also be aware of any strange buzzing, humming, or popping noises coming from your breaker. These sounds indicate that the breaker has been overloaded and is having trouble providing electricity. You should switch off all of the appliances connected to the circuit and replace the breaker right away to prevent any further damage.

4. Lights Flicker More Frequently

When your lights flicker because the light bulb is loose, that’s one thing, but if they’re flickering more frequently than usual, then there’s more than likely something wrong with your breaker. Flickering light fixtures can be a sign that the circuit is about to overload and therefore a proper inspection is needed.

To confirm that the flickering is caused by a bad breaker, it’s best to switch off the power and inspect the device visually. Also, check for any loose connections that could be contributing to the problem.

5. Tripped Breaker Won’t Stay in Reset Position

One sure sign of a bad breaker is that it trips and won’t stay in the reset position. You try and turn the breaker switch back on, only for it to trip again and again, like a stubborn child refusing to obey their parent’s commands. No matter what you do, from switching off appliances to plugging directly into a different circuit, nothing seems to stop it from tripping as soon as you flick it back on.

6. Unexplained Outages

If you experience frequent power outages or even momentary dimming of lights or flickering of appliances, chances are your breaker isn’t doing its job properly. It may be unable to handle the electric load inside your home and thus trips itself off to prevent a dangerous overload. If a particular circuit in your house keeps tripping for no reason, it could be an indication that the breaker is past its prime and needs to be replaced.

How Do I Know if my GFCI Breaker is Bad?

Are you worried that your GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter) breaker may be bad? If so, you’re not alone! Many people are concerned about the life expectancy of a GFCI breaker and how to tell when it’s time to replace one. GFCI breakers are an essential part of protecting our homes from potential short circuits and other electrical hazards.

Both the International Residential Code (IRC) and the National Electric Code (NEC) define a Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI) as:

Ground-Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI). A device intended for the protection of personnel that functions to de-energize a circuit or portion thereof within an established period of time when a current to ground exceeds the values established for a Class A device.

This is the technical definition but basically a Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter is a safety device used in electrical systems that help prevent electrocution by automatically breaking the connection if an unbalanced amount of electricity flows through the system.

This unbalanced flow is often caused by damaged or frayed wiring or faulty outlets, or even moisture getting into the circuit. This is one of the reasons why GFCI outlets are often found in bathrooms, kitchens, laundry rooms, basements, and other areas of the home where water is frequent.

When the GFCI detects this unbalanced flow of electricity, it quickly shuts off the power supply to protect people from being shocked or electrocuted. The critical thing to remember is that GFCIs save lives – but only if they function properly!

Signs of a Bad GFCI Breaker

Although you should always test your GFCI breaker to be sure, there are a few tell-tale signs that it may have gone bad:

1. Tripping or Failing to Reset Properly

A malfunctioning GFCI breaker may trip or fail to reset properly. Check the GFCI breaker to see if it trips when you plug in an appliance or turn on a light switch. If the breaker doesn’t reset properly, then it may be time for a replacement.

When your GFCI breaker trips too easily or unnecessarily, then it may be time to replace the device. Also, if you have to repeatedly reset your breaker after it trips, then chances are something is wrong with it.

2. Buzzing, Humming, or Popping Noises When Operating or Plugging in Appliances

Sounds are usually indicative of electrical problems such as faulty wiring connections or poor performance. It’s either that or your breaker is wearing out. If you hear a loud hum or buzzing sound when you plug in an appliance or turn on the lights, it’s time to investigate further.

3. The Test Button Does Not Function Properly

A test button found in one of your outlets is an indication that you have a GFCI breaker. If the button does not stick when pressed, is stuck in the on or off position, or the test button doesn’t trip the breaker after being reset, then it’s a no-brainer; there’s something wrong with it.

4. Visible Damage on Breaker Box or Breakers

Carefully inspect your breaker box or breakers. Physical damage on either the breaker box or breakers, such as cracks in the plastic casing, could indicate that something is wrong inside and should be addressed immediately.

5. Burning Smells Coming from the Outlet or Breaker Box When Plugging in an Appliance

Burning smells suggest that there is excessive heat buildup somewhere in the circuit which could potentially start a fire if not addressed quickly enough. While the GFCI can help prevent a short circuit or shock, it won’t protect you from potential fire hazards, especially when something’s wrong with it.

If you feel your GFCI breaker is malfunctioning, consider replacing it as soon as possible. Safety should always be a top priority and never be overlooked regarding electrical hazards.

If you’re unsure how to replace your GFCI breaker, consult a licensed electrician for help. They can assist you in properly diagnosing the problem and ensuring that everything is safe and up to code. As always, exercise caution when dealing with any electrical wiring or appliances. Taking the necessary precautions can ensure that you, your family, and your home are safe from any potential hazards.

Why Should I Care if my GFCI Breaker is Bad?

It’s important to check your GFCI breaker on a regular basis to make sure it is functioning properly. If you suspect it may be faulty, test it with a voltage meter or call in an electrician for help. A malfunctioning GFCI can leave you vulnerable to electrical shocks and other hazards.

How Do You Know if You Have a Bad Arc Fault Breaker?

Arc Fault Breakers are an important safety feature in our homes and workplaces and are designed to be sensitive to electrical arcs that can cause electrical fires.

Both the International Residential Code (IRC) and the National Electric Code (NEC) define an Arc Fault Circuit Interrupter (AFCI) as:

Arc-Fault Circuit Interrupter (AFCI). A device intended to provide protection from the effects of arc faults by recognizing characteristics unique to arcing and by functioning to deenergize the circuit when an arc fault is detected.

Electrical arcs are caused by loose wires or faulty electrical connections, and arc fault breakers are designed to detect these irregularities and deenergize the circuit once detected.

However, sometimes they may malfunction or become outdated, leaving your property vulnerable.

Signs of a Bad AFCI Breaker

Most of the time, the signs of a bad arc fault breaker are similar to other kinds of breakers, but here is a short list you should watch out for:

1. Humming Noises

One of the most common indicators is strange buzzing or humming noises coming from the breaker box, usually followed by tripping or resetting of circuit breakers. This noise is caused by an internal malfunction, which causes the breaker to trip more often than usual and could be indicative of a serious problem with your arc fault breaker.

2. Trips Without Any Clear Reason

If it trips when there’s no current running through it, this could mean that the device has been damaged and needs to be replaced. The tripping can also be accompanied by sparks, smoke, or burning smells coming from the breaker box, which are all clear signs of an issue with your arc fault breaker.

3. Black Marks on Your Wall Outlets

Additionally, black marks on your wall outlets near the bad arc fault breaker and discoloration or burn marks on its components are both very concerning indicators that your device has been damaged. These signs could also signify other electrical problems in your home, such as overheating wires, loose wiring connections, or a serious issue with your breaker box.

In any case, it’s never wise to ignore these signs, and you should always have a certified electrician inspect your outlet if you suspect an issue with your arc fault breaker. Taking the extra time can save you from potential hazards such as fire or shock that could put both yourself and your property at risk.

4. Flickering Lights

Some people often think of flickering lights as a sign of a faulty appliance; however, this could actually be an indication that your arc fault breaker is malfunctioning. If the lights in certain parts of your home are flickering and accompanied by other signs, such as buzzing or humming noises, this is usually a sign that your arc fault breaker needs to be replaced.

How to Test for a Bad Breaker Yourself?

If you’re still uncertain if your breaker is working correctly, there are several ways to test its functionality yourself. First, start by turning off the power to the circuit and unscrewing the faceplate of the outlet. Once you have access to the wires inside, use an ohm meter or continuity tester to check for any irregular readings or shorts. If you encounter any, it means that your breaker is likely malfunctioning and needs to be replaced immediately.

Here is a short tutorial video on how to check for a bad breaker:

Once you’ve identified any irregularities or other signs of a bad circuit breaker, it’s important to contact a qualified electrician to inspect and repair. Although this may require an investment in time and money, taking the necessary steps to ensure the safety of your home is always worth it.

Also if you want to test the breaker yourself and don’t have an ohm meter, you can check this one out on Amazon:

AstroAI Multimeter 2000 Counts Digital Multimeter
42,666 Reviews
AstroAI Multimeter 2000 Counts Digital Multimeter
  • VERSATILE DIGITAL MULTIMETER - Accurately measures AC/DC Voltage, DC Current, Resistance, and Diode. This Multimeter is a really useful tool for solving industrial and household electrical issues. Suitable for Household Outlets, Fuses, Batteries (including Vehicles), Automotive Circuit Troubleshooting, Charging System, Testing electronics in Cars etc.
  • TROUBLESHOOTING WITH ACCURACY - This Multimeter has a sampling speed of 2 times per second; Built-in a backlight LCD display with 3 ½ digits (1999 count) 0.6”, and high polarity including negative and positive readings.
  • ENSURES SAFETY - Double ceramic fuse is anti-burn and protects from overloading.The silicone cover is able to protect the multimeter from failing damage and prevent electric shocks. And low battery indication will be displayed when battery power is low.

How to Replace a Bad Circuit Breaker?

Many people don’t realize that their circuit breaker fails and needs to be replaced from time to time with a new circuit breaker. Based on the information above, check if you have a bad circuit breaker, and these can be easily identified by a few key symptoms. If you’re experiencing any of these, it’s likely time to replace your circuit breaker:

  • The breaker trips without explanation or warning
  • Lights dim unexpectedly or flicker
  • Overheating occurs in the area surrounding the breaker

If you’ve identified that your breaker is bad and needs to be replaced, here are the steps you can follow:

1. Turn Off the Main Power Switch

The first step is to switch off your main power switch before attempting to replace the breaker. This will prevent any danger from arising during the process.

2. Remove the Panel Cover

Once you’ve ensured that all power is switched off, remove the panel cover of your circuit breaker and locate the faulty one. Make sure to take a look at the breaker rating before you unplug it. Use nose pliers with rubber handles to delicately disconnect the wires from the faulty breaker.

3. Replace the Breaker

Carefully remove the faulty breaker and replace it with a new one that matches the specifications of your electrical system. You can order this online or get it from your nearest hardware store. This typically costs less than $5.

Make sure to follow all safety precautions while doing this, such as wearing gloves and avoiding contact with bare wires.

4. Reconnect the Wires

Once the new breaker is in place, reconnect all of the wires as they were before and ensure that they are properly secured in their positions. Ensure that the breaker is in its on position before you connect the wires to the terminal.

5. Test the Breaker

The last step is to test the new breaker. Switch on your main power switch and check if everything works as it should.

Here is an in-depth tutorial video on how you can replace the circuit breaker yourself:

However, if you don’t have any experience in dealing with electricity or if you’re unsure about the safety of replacing the breaker yourself, having someone equipped with the right knowledge and tools can save you a lot of time, energy, and hassle. Hiring a professional electrician is always a safe bet when dealing with electrical systems, as they will ensure that the job is done correctly and efficiently.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bad Breakers

Below is a list of frequently asked questions about bad breakers.

Will a Bad Breaker Keep Tripping?

We’ve already established that most of the time, a bad breaker trips for no apparent reason. It’s a surefire sign that something isn’t functioning properly and should be inspected as soon as possible.

When talking about breakers, they are generally considered “bad” when they are faulty or malfunctioning in some way. This could mean that the breaker has become worn out from regular use over time, or there may have been an installation mistake that caused it to work improperly. Either way, when you have a bad breaker, it’ll keep on tripping until the underlying electrical issues are addressed.

Can a Bad Breaker Cause Lights to Dim?

Being in a room with dimmed lights can be an unpleasant experience, and it’s also an indication that something may be defective somewhere in the wiring. Could it be that a bad breaker is to blame for these subtle shifts in brightness? It’s possible, as improper power delivery could certainly leave you with lights that are forever begging for a bit more energy.

When your electrical system isn’t properly wired, it can lead to a drop in the voltage that is delivered to the lights, resulting in them not receiving enough power to function optimally. Lights that are continuously dimmed may be a sign of a breaker that is no longer working correctly, so it’s always best to contact a licensed electrician if you’re experiencing this issue.

Do I Have a Bad Double Pole Circuit Breaker or a Single Pole Breaker?

Trying to figure out whether or not you have a bad double-pole breaker or a single-pole breaker can be a real challenge; all the wires and labels on the switchboard of the service panel start to look the same. To help you determine which one you have, here are a few things to look out for:

Double pole breakers usually read 240 volts, while single pole breakers generally only read 120 volts. If you check the voltage reading of your breaker and it’s not matching one of these, or it turns out to be 0, then you may have a faulty switch.

The problem lies when you get a 120V reading – how will you know if you have a single pole breaker and or a faulty double pole circuit breaker?

It’s easy – check your electrical panel. A double pole breaker will have two switches next to each other, while a single pole breaker will only have one. If you do see two switches side by side, the chances are good that the switch is a double pole circuit breaker – in which case it could be faulty and needs to be replaced with a new one.

Should You Update to a Modern Breaker?

The majority of fault breakers currently on the market are designed to detect and stop even the smallest of electrical irregularities, making them one of the most efficient safety devices for any property. Updating to a more modern breaker can provide you with greater peace of mind, knowing that your home is always safeguarded from potentially hazardous conditions.

In addition to their advanced features, many modern breakers are compatible with other safety devices such as surge protectors and GFCI. This provides you with an added layer of protection for your home against power surges, overloads, and other electrical mishaps.

Older breakers often become less reliable over time and may not have the same safety features as newer models. Upgrading to a modern breaker will provide you with a reliable and effective way to ensure the safety of your home and family.

Final Thoughts

Faulty circuit breakers can be dangerous if not addressed in a timely manner and can also lead to costly repairs, so it’s always a good idea to check if you have a bad breaker before the issue gets worse. Understanding the signs that you have a bad circuit breaker, and knowing how to replace it, are key steps in ensuring the safety and efficiency of your electrical system. If you’re ever in doubt about any part of this process, don’t hesitate to consult a professional.